Stuffing Or Southern Corn Bread Dressing for Thanksgiving?
Will you serve Stuffing or Southern Corn Bread Dressing with your Turkey this year for Thanksgiving?
I honestly have never eaten Stuffing and I wouldn't even know how to prepare it. All I have ever known is having SCBD for Thanksgiving. If I'm not mistaken (feel free to correct me if I am wrong) but the key difference between the two, lies in the cooking methods as well as a few different ingredients.
Cornbread dressing, in particular, emphasizes bold, earthy flavors, distinguishing it from bread-based stuffings. I personally prefer Cornbread Dressing with a good bit of sage added and the rich turkey broth that makes it have such a wonderful flavor.
I am assuming, that with Stuffing, it is always cooked INSIDE of the Turkey?? This is actually a question because I really do not know. What I do know is that Cornbread Dressing is a separate dish that accompanies the Turkey.
We only have Dressing once or twice a year...at Thanksgiving and sometimes again at Christmas. For me, Dressing is a dish of Memories and Tradition. Memories of my mother's fabulous dressing makes my mouth water even today.
The preparation process is often a combined effort from mostly the ladies in the family. I remember watching my mother prepare all the ingredients but I often say I wish I had make written notes rather than mental notes when helping her make the dressing. Most of the time, the family recipe is handed down from generation to generation and it is "THAT" recipe which represents the RICH family history of cooking the Thanksgiving meal.
Family Thanksgiving 2021 at Trista's and Ty's (oldest daughter and son-in-law)As my family gathers around to eat for the Holiday season, it will be my hopes that the traditions of the past continue to enrich the present, one DELICIOUS bite at a time.
My Moms Southern Cornbread Dressing Recipe:
For the cornbread:
2 cups yellow cornmeal
1 cup all-purpose flour
1 Tbsp baking powder
1 tsp salt
2 large eggs
2 cups buttermilk
1/4 cup melted butter
For the Dressing:
1 pan of crumbled cornbread
8 slices of white bread stale or toasted and crumbled
1 sleeve saltine crackers crushed
1 stick butter
1 large onion chopped
4 stalks celery finely chopped
4 cups Turkey broth or Young Hen broth
2 tsp dried sage (or to taste)
1/2 tsp black pepper
3 large eggs (beaten)
optional: 1 cup of cooked shredded chicken or turkey
Instructions:
Preheat oven to 425 degrees, Grease a cast-iron skillet.
In a large bowl, whisk together cornmeal, flour, baking powder, slat, and baking soda.
In a separate bowl, mx eggs, buttermilk and melted butter. Add the wet ingredients to the dry ingredients and mix until just combined.
Pour batter into cast-iron skillet and bake for 20-25 minutes.
Let the cornbread cool, the crumble into a large mixing bowl.
Prepare the Dressing:
Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Grease a 9 x 13 inch baking dish.
In a skillet, melt butter over med heat. Add onions and celery, cooking until soft and translucent
In the mixing bowl with the crumbled cornbread, add the crumbled bread, crushed crackers, cooked onion and celery, sage and black pepper.
Gradually stir in the broth, one cup at a time, until the mixture is moist but not soupy. Taste and adjust seasonings as needed.
Add the beaten eggs and optional chicken or turkey. Stir until incorporated.
Transfer the mixture to the prepared baking dish.
Bake uncovered for 40-50 minutes, or until the top is golden brown and crispy and the center is set.
That is it Folks!!! Delicious Southern Cornbread Dressing... Don't forget the giblet gravy!!
HaPpY MoNdaY....
shug
This looks so good! I hate to tell you this, but we have stovetop stuffing. My family really likes it, but I am sure yours is better! Thanks for the recipe.
ReplyDeleteI am sure your stove top stuffing taste very good. I do need to give it a try. Happy Thanksgiving.
DeleteI have had both. Year ago when we were in the Service a little gal from Tennessee made cornbread stuffing for Christmas dinner and I made the turkey. Plain bread stuffing has many varieties, my grandmother made hers with raisins and apple and it was the best ever! I have tried to recreate her recipe...I come close but not exact.
ReplyDeleteYour grandmother's stuffing sounds very good with the raisins and apples. I do need to try it sometime.
DeleteSince my parents came from New England, it was always stuffing for us. It wasn't until I met Danny that I was introduced to cornbread stuffing, and it is delicious! We aren't cooking at home this year as we don't have family coming for the holidays. Hope your Thanksgiving is blessed, Shug!
ReplyDeleteI love how there are diverse ways right here in the USA. I do hope you and Danny enjoy a nice quite Thanksgiving.
Deletemy mother made this dressing, since I don't like onions or celery, I never ate it. she did all the cooking, I bought the food. I despise cooking. all cooking and when I do cook you can tell I don't like it. ha ha. when I married Bob, he wanted TG ad Christmas dinner, traditional and I said, I don't cook turkey or dressing. he read the instructions, made a fine turkey and mad his mothers recipe for potato stuffing. he is a born Yankee and they do not eat cornbread or greens or black eye peas, but he does now. I love the potatoes stuffing, have to pick out the onions, and my kids fought over who would take the most of it home with them.
ReplyDeleteYou make me laugh with all your non-cooking skills. I have to be in the mood to cook or else, it feels more like a chore. We have a Yankee son-in-law and his family always served stuffing. He is a good one and he eats my dressing with no complaints.
DeleteOh, stuffing is a must for the Thanksgiving dinner. When we make ours, it's just a plain and simple recipe, but it's a wonderful side dish for sure. I've never heard of the Southern Corn Bread Dressing, but it sounds delicious. And I loved hearing about your mom preparing the dressing, and you watching her. These old stories are so special, and I love hearing about the women in our families, who carried on the traditions that we have now. They are a great part of us today, and I treasure the things that were taught to me by the older generations. This is a cute picture of your daughter by the fire pit. I know you'll do great making the stuffing, Shug. You have so many talents and are a creative person. : )
ReplyDeleteIt's snowing here today! The first snow is always so special. : )
~Sheri
Thank you Sheri. My crew loves the dressing and most likely will make it back to my house for dinner that evening for round 2.....
DeleteFood does bring back memories doesn't it and good times. I love cornbread stuffing and I love regular stuffing. We are going to Ohio and my DIL makes stuffing with bread -and it is delicious too!
ReplyDeleteYou are so right...Food brings us a lot of comforting memories. Hope you all enjoy your trip and a wonderful Thanksgiving.
ReplyDeleteThank you so, for inviting us into your family's kitchen! My DIL usually makes cornbread dressing, but this year we're letting Publix prepare the whole shebang. (I still smile remembering how she corrected us when we referred to it as stuffing. "Nooo! Here in the South we "dress" our turkeys!"
ReplyDeleteLove that personalized Thanksgiving card!
We make stuffing here. Aside from the bread there's usually onion, celery and sausage in it
ReplyDeleteOh yes indeed, Food does bring on the memories. I had to smile at don't forget the gizzard gravy. At my Mother in Laws she always put gizzards in the gravy...much to the loud remarks of my hubby and his brother. They would rant and rave over the "horrible" stuff as they ate every last bit of it.
ReplyDeleteWe always had and have stuffing made with celery, onions broth, butter and loads of poultry seasonings. Usually it was put in the bird. I find now that Dave and I are the only ones that like it now..some traditions die hard. I'm going to make a small pan to bring to my DIL's for Thanksgiving. Gotta have some.
Sue
You are right! Stuffing got it's name because it is stuffed in the turkey. Dressing is usually served on the side. It's wonderful that you have the original recipe, to be handed down through the generations.
ReplyDeleteI used to love my mother's stuffing, but we no longer have an oven. Just an InstantPot, microwave, and electric hotplate just in case. How pathetic is that?!
ReplyDeleteI had the best of both worlds - mom was from Ohio and was the “northerner” as my grandma would refer to her and Dad was from East Tennessee. He grew up eating cornbread stuffing which he thought was dry and didn’t like - much to my grandma’s dislike- mom grew up with the bread stuffing. Mom’s stuffing always was stuffed in the bird and I did that until I read it wasn’t safe to do that - although we never got sick. For years I used San Francisco sourdough bread for my bread stuffing. It was good but my sons don’t care for my stuffing and only like stove top! I give up! 🤦🏼♀️ They had it at some friends house and ranted and raved about it! One son, only likes canned jelled cranberries. I can’t get fancy at all with them! 🤨 Comfort foods are what makes the holiday feasts delicious and memorable.
ReplyDeletestuffing here with anything with a cavity and roasted and baked - I'm from New Zealand ...
ReplyDeleteI prefer cornbread dressing made in a separate pan. My daughter-in-love makes a delicious dressing with chicken added and it's become a fan favorite. I like my dressing on the drier side, rather than soupy (yuck). Now I'm hungry for dressing!
ReplyDeletegreat idea... we will try this menu for Thanksgiving.....
ReplyDeleteHappy Thanksgiving to you and your families....